
As we’ve come to expect for the last several decades (the past three or so), Summertime is a “super-time” at the multiplex (and the box office). Bonnie’s toy box burst open the season officially last weekend, so it’s time for a comic book crusader to literally swoop in and rescue us from the warm-weather duldrums. Mind you, we met lots of aliens a couple of weeks ago with Spielberg’s newest, so film fans should be primed for an even friendlier “strange visitor from another planet”. Nope, it’s not the newest version of “big blue”, but rather his cousin. This harkens back to the strategy of the producers of his “touchstone” big screen outing of 1978. The late, great Christopher Reeve donned the cape for three outings before a “spin-off”. Of course, the dynamic team of James Gunn and Peter Safran, the keepers of the DC film franchise, isn’t following that “playbook”, so now we’re meeting the “girl of steel”, SUPERGIRL.
In the story’s opening moments, the title character, AKA Kara Zor-El (Milly Alcock), has been “over-celebrating” her 23rd birthday. She’s trying to “sleep it off”, but her faithful puppy Krypto will have none of that. Neither will her cousin Clark AKA Superman (David Corenswet), who transmits a video “B-day” greeting to her spaceship/crashpad. That vessel is parked on a “red sun” planet, so Kara’s enduring a full-on hangover. Down the way, the home of a weapons crafter named Elias Knoll gets a most-unwelcome visit from the sadistic leader of the space pirates known as the Brigands, Krem (Matthias Schoenaerts). The tension escalates into a brutal attack that leaves a single survivor of the Knoll family, teenager Ruthye (Eve Ridley). Later, she shows up at a “watering hole”, seeking an “agent of revenge”. This leads to Ruthye befriending Kara, who takes her back to her ship. Unfortunately, the Brigands are there to steal it. Krypto breaks free and charges Krem, who shoots the pooch with a poison dart. After the thieves escape, Kara takes her pet to a vet who explains that unless she gets the antidote from Krem, Krypto will be heading to that “farm up north”. Kara has no choice but to accompany Ruthye on her “trackdown” of the Brigand “king”. Even if Kara can get to a “yellow sun” planet, will her superpowers be enough to save her poor canine pal in time? And what happens when their quest leads to the savage, surly space-hoppin’ bounty hunter Lobo (Jason Momoa)? The clock is ticking…
After a steady acting career, mainly in several TV shows (broadcast and streaming), Ms. Alcock puts a very different spin on this iconic hero. There’s little of the wide-eyed innocence of Helen Slater in the 1984 flick, nor the feisty “working gal” energy of the CW’s Melissa Benoist. Instead, she goes dark, conveying the character’s traumatized past and her need to self-medicate. Kara needs a reason to soar again. Luckily, we get a glimpse of her sunny side as she interacts with the ever-adorable “fuzz-faced” Krypto. Alcock is more than up to this daunting challenge. Oh, that “reason” is Ruthye played with steel-eyed focus and determination by the engaging Ms. Ridley. Her road to revenge leads her to a new family: a needed “big sister” in Kara. These actresses work well with each other, even as they share exchanges with the movie’s big scene-stealer, Momoa, as the ill-tempered, gamma-irradiated boss biker Lobo. His grungy charm and snarky asides propel the often dour space opera. Though he was a JLA member in the “Snyder-verse”, Momoa appears to be having a lot more fun as this DC comics fan favorite “anti-hero”. He fares much better than the talented Schoenaerts, who isn’t given a real chance to shine as the underwritten Krem. With his “bedazzled” face, he looks as though he took a wrong exit off “Fury Road”. Krem exists to inflict cruelty as he mugs and sneers at the heroes. Speaking of heroes, it’s great to see Corenswet return as the caring “blue boy scout” mentor to his cousin (though it feels like a “big brother/lil’ sis” dynamic).
Unlike last Summer’s “super spectacle” from James Gunn, this is helmed by an action flick “newbie” Craig Gillespie (I, TONYA, CRUELLA, and DUMB MONEY). In many ways, the film doesn’t harken back to SUPERMAN, but rather Gunn’s work at Marvel on the GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY trilogy, with the countless slimy “beasties” and exotic alien backdrops. However, it’s a lot tougher to see these creative designs (unlike the GoG flicks) in the barely-lit scenes, giving everything a muddy look, rather than the “lived-in” STAR WARS aesthetic. This makes it doubly difficult to follow the chaotic fights and stunts. We eventually get too comfortable with the weird (did we need the “potty” gags?) and try to latch on to the familiar. A big contributor to that inertia is the cliche-ridden screenplay, based on a popular comic book miniseries. It takes its main idea from TRUE GRIT as Ruthye is a sword-wielding Mattie Ross (with nods to CAT BALLOU and even THE SEVEN SAMURAI). This leads to lots of “plot point” tropes as the hero is wounded and must heal before a final throw-down (we saw that a few weeks ago in THE MANDALORIAN AND GROGU). I did find the flashbacks to the destruction of the planet Krypton compelling, along with life on the floating rock called Argo City, even as the talented David Krumholtz, as Kara’s pop Zor-El, provides SF-science babble in Kryptonese (couldn’t they have switched to English after a few lines of it). And, as I mentioned earlier, Lobo is a welcome shot of adrenaline in his “drop-bys” (I’m sure a solo flick is in the works). I recall that several DC comics films were stopped because Gunn and Safran stated that the scripts “weren’t there”. As this film lurched to its too-protracted finale, I wondered why this one was “ready to go”. And I also counted the weeks until that webbed-wonder swings in for a welcome return visit. But we’re concerned with “the guys down the street” (as Deadpool says), and this is a pretty “meh” follow-up to last Summer’s triumphant “reboot”. That one soared while SUPERGIRL, despite a superb cast, barely gets off the ground.
2 Out of 4
SUPERGIRL opens in theatres everywhere on Friday, June 26, 2026










