– by Cate Marquis –
FATHERLAND is Polish director Pawel Pawlikowski’s rich, insightful fictionalized historic drama about Nobel Prize-winning novelist Thomas Mann (Hanns Zischler) and his daughter Erika Mann (Sandra Huller) traveling to West Germany to accept a literary award at the height of the Cold War. It is the first time the author has returned to the country of his birth after fleeing when Hitler took power in 1933.
Thomas Mann, now living in the U.S., is traveling to Frankfurt in America-dominated West Germany to accept the revived Goethe Award, named for someone Mann admires and also sees as a symbol of the potential for a “good German” culture, an ideal to which Mann clings now that the war is over. His daughter Erika Mann is doubtful about dream but she dutifully accompanies her now-elderly father on this trip. Before the Nazis came to power, Thomas Mann had been an outspoken opponent of Nazi ideas and Hitler, which put him at risk as well as being married to a Jewish-German woman, Katia, the daughter of mathematician and artist Alfred Pringsheim. When Hitler did take power, Mann’s oldest children Erika and Klaus advised him to not return from Switzerland, where he was visiting at the time, advice he took.
This is the third of Pawlikowski’s post-WWII dramas, following IDA and COLD WAR. The moving, intelligent FATHERLAND also grapples with the personal damage to survivors left by the war, as well as physical devastation. The title has a double meaning, both Germany and Erika Mann’s father’s hopeful dreams of a better Germany, embodied by Goethe.
Erika has no wish to return to Germany but agrees to accompany her now-elderly father on his visit. Before they start, she talks by phone with her beloved brother Klaus (August Diehl), a troubled gay man living in Cannes, to ask him to join them, which he is reluctant to do.
Once in West Germany, Mann is disappointed by the things he finds. While Mann arrives hopeful for a Germany more like the one before the rise of fascism, and gives a hopeful speech after the award. Mann has received hate mail, calling him a traitor for leaving Germany, as soon as he arrived in Germany, and at the reception, he finds ex-Nazis and Nazi collaborators hoping he can help them find a way back into acceptance, including a man hoping to attach the famous writer’s name to a revival of a Wagnerian festival that was a favorite of Hitler’s and Erika’s Nazi ex-husband, also hoping to exploit a tenuous link.
The drama, beautifully shot in a black-and-white that perfectly evokes the time period, explores post-war Germany, the Cold War tensions and family dynamics. The acting is superb, moving and heartbreaking, as the drama intelligently explores the relationship between father and daughter, an accomplished person in her own right, and a number of issues, philosophical/political and personal.
Discouraged by what he finds in West Germany, Mann decides to also accept the East German version of the Goethe Award that he has also been offered. The ceremony is in Wiemar, where Goethe was born, but the town is now in Soviet-controlled East Germany, which means crossing the border into the communist country. Erika is worried how that decision might impact his ability to return to the U.S. but she is unable to dissuade her father. Even when he hears tragic family news, Mann presses on.
The drama then becomes a kind of road trip as Erika serves as both her famous father’s driver and assistant. Father and daughter embark on a cross-country journey through a war-devastated landscape. In East Germany, Mann is again disappointed, as he finds both a government who covets a Nobel Prize winner, tempting him with offer of a prestigious position, and signs of political repression.
Shot beautifully shot in a black-and-white, the historical drama perfectly evokes the time period, as it explores post-war Germany, the Cold War tensions and family dynamics. The acting is superb, particularly Sandra Huller, moving and heartbreaking, as the drama intelligently explores the relationship between father and daughter, who is an accomplished person in her own right, as well as a number of issues, philosophical/political and personal.
“Fatherland,” in German with English subtitles, opens Friday, Nov. 20, at the Hi Pointe Theater.
RATING: 3.5 out of 4 stars









