
Hey, I know we were just there last month with LEE CRONIN’S THE MUMMY, but don’t you feel like making another visit to the “guys and ghouls” that reside at that creepy ole’ “Blumhouse”? Now, I’m not referring to an actual piece of decrepit real estate, but rather a movie production company that’s known mainly for cinematic terror tales, much like Hammer and Amicus over in the UK so long ago. This time out, they’re dipping into a bag of magical “thingamabobs” for a cautionary tale with a sardonic and very black sense of humor. So forget that dusty monkey’s paw and toss out the Arabian lamp, because this “deliverer of all desires” just may become your new OBSESSION. But, as the saying goes, “be careful what you wish for”. Very, very careful…
In the opening scene, we meet the story’s main protagonist, the morose, brooding “Bear” (Michael Johnston). He’s on a most precarious mission, not a big heist or a quest for treasures. No, he’s desperate to escape the “friend zone” in order to start a serious romantic relationship with his music store co-worker Nikki (Inde Navarrette). Bear just has to find the perfect moment to make his case. Perhaps it will be tonight after some bar trivia with two other “retail slaves”, Ian (Cooper Tomlinson) and Sarah (Megan Lawless). Oh, but a “pet emergency” has him backing out when he talks to Nikki on the phone. Bear hears some racket on her end, and Nikki says that she just accidentally dropped her crystal necklace down a drain. Ah ha! This could provide an “in.” Bear runs down to the “new age” trinket store for a replacement. But something else catches his eye. It’s a weird “Tchoksy” called “One Wish Willow”. This “old timey” toy guarantees that your wish will be granted after breaking it in two (it’s a wand-like wooden stick). At the end of the trivia night, Bear gives Nikki a lift home from the pub. And he botches his “pitch”. After an awkward goodnight, she heads toward her door. His frustration pushes Bear into giving this “new-old” toy a try (a “break”, really). He wants her complete and consuming love… and Nikki stops in her tracks and returns to his car. From then on, they’re a nearly inseparable couple. But Ian and Sarah think they’re also insufferable. Nikki begins to undergo a huge personality change, lying about her family and exhibiting even more extremely disturbing behavior (some odd culinary creations, for one thing). Yes, she is obsessing over him, hence the title. A desperate Bear calls the 800 number on the OWW box. The odd fella at the call center tells him that there are no “take-backs.” The only way to break the “wish” is for the “wisher” to die! Talk about an unbearable dilemma (sorry ’bout that)!
I suppose the main focus of the story is the “audience surrogate” Bear, played with a twitchy awkwardness by the energetic Johnston. He’s something of an “everyman”, full of yearning, but little confidence. It takes Bear a while to realize the full impact and awful consequences of his actions, but when it “kicks in,” Johnston is a sweaty ball of pure panic. But the film’s real “breakout” star is the amazing Ms. Navarrette, who impressed me for the last few years as Lana Lang’s daughter Sarah on the CW’s “Superman and Lois”. Oh, she has made the leap to the big screen with a gonzo, “go for broke” tour de force performance as the bewitched Nikki, a “dreamgirl” who suddenly becomes a nightmare. The switch in vocal intensity and her incredible physical contortions (and those rubbery facial expressions) earn her a spot in the loopy ladies of terror “hall of fame”, right next to Glen Close as Alex of FATAL ATTRACTION and Jennifer Jason Leigh’s Hedy in SINGLE WHITE FEMALE. Yet, somehow, Ms. N conveys Nikki’s tragic fate behind the frozen smiles (best shown during a nocturnal plea). To think she was the “sweetheart of Smallville”. Much of the standard comic relief is provided by Tomlinson as the party “bro” who is not quite the supportive “wing man” that he projects. Lawless exudes a tenderness behind the tough-talking punk chic stylings of the concerned and sympathetic Sarah. One of the more pleasant surprises is the supporting turn by a beloved TV comedy icon as the quartet’s befuddled boss (IMDB lists him, but I just can’t bring myself to spoil it).
It’s tough to believe that this is only the second feature from writer/director Curry Barker, as this is one terror tale brimming with confidence and a wonky style. And, perhaps due to his stand-up comedy past, a wicked sense of humor, from snarky satire to silly slapstick. Sure, we’ve gotten many variations of the “wish fulfilled” themes of regret, but Barker’s put a fresh spin in them, while harkening back to the “can men and women be friends” issues of WHEN HARRY MET SALLY (miss ya’ Rob) and even ALADDIN (Robin’s Genie can’t zap Jasmine into loving that “strett rat”). Barker also captures the intense “forced bonding” that occurs with “workmates”, especially those in their early 20’s. It’s a snarky sneer at old romcom cliches, even down to the “falling in love” montage (love the eyeroll from Sarah). Although the marketing gurus give away too much in the ads, this off-kilter, creepy romp still has lots of surprises and delivers on the scares with a sense of hopelessness and dread from one selfish little act. It’s just a shame that the film doesn’t quite “stick the landing” as the last act feels too rushed and the ending denouncement falls a bit flat (I want to stay with the duo for a few more minutes). Even with that caveat, those horror fans who have missed the mirth in the macabre may or may not be obsessed, but they should be entertained by OBSESSION. I wonder if they tried to get the rights to that old Jiminy Cricket tune?
3 Out of 4
OBSESSION opens in theatres everywhere on May 15, 2026

















