HAMLET – Review

It is fairly common to see Shakespearean plays re-set in a different time, sometimes retaining Shakespeare’s language and largely just changing costumes and settings, or sometimes re-writing the dialog while retaining mostly the plot. Director Aneil Karia’s new HAMLET, starring Riz Ahmed, does something different and more effective, retaining Shakespeare’s words but uses visual storytelling to place the story wholly in a modern setting, in this case of a wealthy British – South Asian family after the death of the billionaire CEO of the family’s large international business, Elsinore. His son Hamlet (Riz Ahmed) is left confused and bereft by his father’s death, and suspicious, even more so, by his uncle Claudius’ (Art Malik) swift move to not only take over the company but to marry Hamlet’s newly-widowed mother Gertrude (Sheeba Chadha).

As Hamlet, Riz Ahmed delivers a powerhouse performance, the success of which is based on Ahmed’s considerable ability to covey a host of information about both the character’s inner state and the social context while movingly speaking his Shakespearean lines. Ahmed does this brilliantly, with seemingly effortless style, making the character entirely of this modern world while beautifully speaking Shakespeare’s poetry. Riz Ahmed’s Hamlet is heartbreaking yet terrifying, in this moving performance. In several recent films, Ahmed has given a number of striking, subtle performances, and hopefully this new one will be a boost to his already-rising star.

In addition to fine acting, the other real strength of this adaptation of “Hamlet” is in it’s visual storytelling. Surprisingly little of Shakespeare’s words needed to be changed to re-set the story, because the film so powerfully conveys the story’s new circumstances by visual means. The film opens with a nearly wordless scene, where we see Hamlet (Riz Ahmed) participating in preparing his father (Avijit Dutt) for cremation, a scene that clearly lets us know a host of things about this family, such as that they are Hindu, British, and wealthy, as well as establishing Hamlet’s devastated emotional state, all within a few moments. The key to all this is in what we see – expressions, body-language, visual details – more than what we hear, so well-crafted performances are required.

Mostly, the play is intact despite the shifted time period, but a few scenes are deleted or redirected in Michael Lesslie’s fine script. Some dialog takes place between different people, and a few characters are eliminated or combined, but the changes serve this retelling well. Often it is the settings and the behavior and tone of the actors that modernize the play, a surprisingly effective approach. Most of the action, and all the emotional power, remains, delightfully so. While the beauty of Shakespeare’s words remain, the nature of some characters, their relationships and intentions, and meanings of scenes are sometimes altered to serve this new modern version.

Riz Ahmed delivers a striking powerhouse performance, and he is on screen nearly the whole time, but he is also well supported by a fine cast. The film eliminates some characters and scenes but sometimes incorporates parts of them in a refreshingly original way. Horatio is absent but some of his role is taken by other characters. Ophelia and Hamlet have more of a relationship, and he confides in her, not Horatio, about seeing a vision of his dead father. Rosencrantz and Gildenstern are also absent but some of their scenes, and hints of their character, at times fall to Laertes, which gives his character a new slant. Fortinbras takes on a new meaning, and other things and characters are re-interpreted, with new dimensions. There are no traveling actors to put on a play, but they are replaced by colorful South Asian dancers.

Polonius, the father of Laertes and Ophelia, is generally portrayed as talkative, meddlesome but well-meaning, but Timothy Spall plays him as a darker, more calculating character, the businessman uncle’s right-hand man, tasked with keeping tabs on Hamlet to head off potential interference in their plans. Morfydd Clark’s Ophelia plays a greater part in the story, as well as being more assertive and involved in what happens. Joe Alwyn’s Laertes is also more complex, Laertes but also a bit Horatio, and a bit of Rosencrantz and Gildenstern, who do not appear in this version. Other characters, and scenes, are transformed, sometimes in surprising ways, yet all the changes support moving the story into its modern form.

Unlike some time-shifted versions, director Aneil Karia puts much more thought into what we see as the actors speak their lines, not just the sets and costumes but their posture, actions, and body-language, along with vocal tone. A great deal of information is transmitted wordlessly in every scene. An example is where Polonius encounters Hamlet as he is strolling and reading a book. In this film, Hamlet is not reading a book but instead, is in his late father’s office, going through business papers and looking for clues, when he is interrupted by Polonius, who asks what he is reading. The words are the same but the meaning is entirely shifted. Another more powerful example is Hamlet’s famous “to be or not to be” soliloquy, delivered while an upset Hamlet is driving his sports car, angrily weaving in and out of traffic, as clear and harrowing a depiction of a young man unbalanced and on the verge of suicide as you can imagine. The scene is powerful and frightening, yet entirely fresh and original.

There is little that is stage-y about this version, and in fact, it is remarkably visually dynamic. The action is not confined to the family’s lush estate or its many, sometimes claustrophobic rooms. Scenes take place all around London, in a club with driving music, driving along city streets, in event spaces, or on lush lawns festooned with party lights, all of which work incredibly well for the film’s storytelling.

Altogether, this HAMLET has to rank as one of the best screen adaptations. It is a remarkable film re-setting of Shakespeare’s drama, a fresh view of Shakespeare’s great classic in a striking, modern setting, yet a version that still retains the original’s emotional power and tragedy while putting it entirely in our world. With outstanding acting, particularly by Riz Ahmed, and excellent visual and production values, this HAMLET is sure to thrill Shakespeare fans as well as general audiences.

HAMLET opens in theaters on Friday, Apr. 10, 2026.

RATING: 4 out of 4 stars

CYRANO – Review

Haley Bennett stars as Roxanne and Peter Dinklage as Cyrano in Joe Wright’s CYRANO, a Metro Goldwyn Mayer Pictures film. Photo credit: Peter Mountain © 2021 Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Pictures Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Peter Dinklage playing Cyrano in a new film adaptation of the beloved story sounded like an excellent idea. Being directed by Joe Wright, who handled costume dramas such as PRIDE AND PREJUDICE so well, made the prospect sound even better. But a few minutes into the new CYRANO, it became clear it had a big problem: it’s a musical.

And not a very good musical at that. While there are those who are happy see everything adapted into a musical, this reviewer is firmly in the opposite camp. Not everything should be a musical, and the new CYRANO is exhibit one in that case.

Still, Peter Dinklage gives a moving, stellar performance as Cyrano de Bergerac in a musical adaptation that is less than stellar. There have been numerous stage and film versions of Edmond Rostand’s play, including Steve Martin’s 1987 contemporary, comic one ROXANNE, and a glorious French one, 1990’s CYRANO DE BERGERAC, starring Gerard Depardieu in his prime. Dinklage has the goods to top that famous performance, and actually does, if one is not too distracted by the mediocre musical numbers.

Personally, I love Rostand’s “Cyrano de Bergerac” and generally I am a sucker for all its various adaptations. I have nothing but pure admiration for the remarkably talented Peter Dinklage and I am also a fan of Joe Wright’s movies generally. But this musical CYRANO is an awkward thing, where the weak musical numbers interrupt the dramatic flow of the adventurous, tragic, romantic tale. Every time the drama builds up to a spell-binding, heart-wrenching arc with well-acted scenes, that spell is broken by a song.

The familiar play is full of romance, swordplay, wordplay, wit, and tragedy. Cyrano de Bergerac (Peter Dinklage) is an aristocrat serving as a soldier, a bold personality and multi-talented man known for his skills as a poet and duelist, as well as his intellect, taste and style. But Cyrano’s confidence undermined by his appearance, which makes him feel no woman could love him. References to his appearance often prompt duels.

Nonetheless, Cyrano is secretly in love with the beautiful, intellectual Roxanne (Haley Bennett), his distant cousin and childhood friend. Roxanne is skillfully avoiding the Count de Guiche (Ben Mendelsohn) who relentlessly pursues her with the intent to make her his mistress. Meanwhile, Roxanne has fallen for a handsome young soldier, Christian (Kelvin Harrison Jr.), whom she has only seen from afar, and she seeks Cyrano’s help. Cyrano and Christian become a team to woo the beautiful Roxanne, with Christian’s good-looks and Cyrano’s beautiful words.

There are things that this Cyrano does get right. It was a brilliant idea to cast the gifted Peter Dinklage in the role of tragic Cyrano. Usually it is Cyrano’s large nose that causes his problems and every version seems to use an actor with a false nose. But here it is height, a surprisingly easy transition, and Dinklage does it marvelously well, squeezing all the brilliance from the sparkling dialog and thrilling us with its mix of brash and tragic. Only a few changes to the dialog were needed and there are few direct references to height, as they are unnecessary.

Further, CYRANO is a visually beautiful production, shot in Italy. The staging, the sets and costumes are all wonderfully lavish and brilliantly colorful. The theater scene that introduces Cyrano, where he chases a bad but popular actor off the stage, is wonderfully comic and brash. The scene where Cyrano and Roxanne meet in the bakery alone, and she tells him she is, is unmatched in its heartbreaking power.

As expected, the gifted Peter Dinklage is excellent with the dramatics, turning the words over with startling power and nuance, He even does well with the singing, with a nice baritone voice. Ben Mendelsohn delivers a striking turn as the sinister de Guiche and Kelvin Harrison Jr. does well as handsome, tongue-tied Christian. Haley Bennett gives a more unusual performance as Roxanne, playing her as a bouncy, girlish free spirit more than the lovely, discerning intellectual she usually is.

Despite Dinklage’s strong performance, it never feels right or comfortable to have this dramatic romantic tragedy periodically interrupted with what are generally silly songs, backed by rather eccentric, if athletically impressive, dancing (fortunately the leads, including Dinklage, are not called on to dance as well).

Most of the songs are forgettable, but there is one exception. It is the song that the soldiers sing as they are being sent off to war, while they write letters to their loved ones in case they do not make it home, which is deeply moving and melodic.

Yet, it is a great role indeed for Dinklage, a brilliant re-imaging, and if this had been a different kind of production, it would have ranked up there with the great French production with Gerard Depardieu in his prime. Dinklage’s performance does exceed that high bar but the production it is in is a distraction. Alas, it is not just the songs that are stumbling blocks but other unevenness in the production. Haley Bennett’s odd choice to play Roxanne as a bouncing, romantic comedy figure rather than a clever, intelligent woman, as Roxanne is usually played, seems to undermine the play’s premise. That Roxanne is a worthy match for the brilliant Cyrano. This Roxanne, while beautiful, seems less a sparkling wit and less perfect for Cyrano.

Bottom line, Peter Dinklage is brilliant in this role, one that is near perfect for him, and his performance makes the film soar in those moments when he dominates the screen. But that soaring emotion, the overall heart of the film, and its dramatic arc are repeatedly deflated by the grafted-on musical numbers. It is really a shame, and those who can get past the distraction of those interruptions, will enjoy this visually beautiful, romantic retelling of the beloved Cyrano de Bergerac with the marvelous Peter Dinklage.

CYRANO opens Friday, Feb. 25, at multiple theaters.

RATING: 2.5 out of 4 stars

BIRDS OF PASSAGE – Review

Rapayet (Jose Acosta) and Zaida (Natalia Reyes) in BIRDS OF PASSAGE. Photo by Mateo Contreras. © Ciudad Lunar / Blond Indian

From the makers of the Oscar-nominated EMBRACE OF THE SERPENT, comes BIRDS OF PASSAGE (Pajaros De Verano), another powerful, innovative exploration of Colombian history told in an unexpected way. The 2016 Oscar-nominated EMBRACE OF THE SERPENT took us on a gorgeous but surreal trip up a Colombian river and through the history of European contact’s impact on indigenous peoples.

This time, that film’s director Ciro Guerra co-directs with producer (and then-wife) Cristina Gallego, while her brother David Gallego returns to provide this new film’s strikingly beautiful cinematography, as he did for EMBRACE OF THE SERPENT. The filmmakers again chose as their subject the impact of outsiders on indigenous peoples of Colombia, basing both films on actual historical sources. But this time it is not the devastating impact of European and American explorers, adventurers and missionaries on indigenous peoples but the origin of the Colombian drug trade. Again, the history is told in an unexpected way, through the experience of one indigenous family in the Guajiro region in northern Colombia. BIRDS OF PASSAGE unfolds as a sweeping, true story-inspired, mythic epic.

While EMBRACE OF THE SERPENT used a surreal, time-bending approach, BIRDS OF PASSAGE takes a more linear one, although still told in a visually striking, lyrical way. Despite being made under difficult personal circumstances (the co-directors divorced during the making of the film), BIRDS OF PASSAGE is an excellent film. It was Colombia’s official submission for the Foreign-Language Oscar, and played at the 2018 Cannes, Toronto, Telluride, Sundance and London film festivals.

BIRDS OF PASSAGE spins a tale of the rise and fall of an indigenous family committed to preserving their traditional beliefs, who are swept up in a pursuit of wealth that chips away at the very traditions they hold dear. It is a story of ambition, greed, and tragedy, set against the onslaught of relentless change.

The film was inspired by a true story, ranging from the late 1960s to the early 1980s, centered on one family of the Wayuu indigenous people.

Rapayet (Jose Acosta) is a young man from a once-great Wayuu family who were mostly wiped out. Raised apart from the traditional life, he is regarded as an outsider for his dealings with non-Wayuu people by the insular indigenous culture, for whom family, tradition and honor are everything. Yet Rapayet is determined to rejoin his family’s village culture.

With the help of a traditional Wayuu mediator, Peregrino (Jose Vicente Cotes), Rapayet asks to marry Zaida (Natalia Reyes), the daughter of the village matriarch Ursula (Carmina Martinez). His proposal is regarded coolly, despite Peregrino’s assurances that Rapayet’s dealings with outsiders increase his prospects for wealth. Unconvinced, Ursula demands a high bride-price (which the film calls a dowry), which sends the young man scrambling to come up with the money.

It is not cocaine but marijuana that launches Colombia on this drug path. Struggling to raise money, Rapayet and his non-Wayuu best friend Moises (John Narvaez), along with one of Rapayet’s few remaining Wayuu relatives, coffee plantation owner Anibal (Juan Bautista Martinez), fall into a scheme to provide marijuana to an American. The decision sets Rapayet on the path to both wealth and imperils his adherence to the traditional life.

Zaida and Ursula’s light-colored skin and the blonde hair of Zaida’s younger brother Leonidas (played as a child by Yanker Diaz and as a teen by Greider Mesa) indicate that the Wayuu have not always lived as apart from the world as their behavior suggests.

The crime family saga might bring to mind THE GODFATHER but the story also evokes Greek tragedy. This film uses an allegorical setting and symbolism, keeping it tied to epic tales and the characters’ indigenous belief system.

While EMBRACE OF THE SERPENT was distinctly surreal and employed a time-bending approach, BIRDS OF PASSAGE takes a more straight-forward one, a single chronological tale, framed as an elder recounting memories, as a cautionary tale to future generations. The device of an old man telling a tale evokes legends, traditional storytelling, and family sagas, but also Greek tragedy and myth. The story is divided into chapters, which are labeled “songs” and given titles suggesting moral theme of these portions in the family’s rise and fall.

The film is well-structured and paced by its co-directors. The cast does an excellent job, particularly Jose Acosta as the conflicted protagonist Rapayet and Carmina Martinez as the fierce matriarch Ursula. The tale gives insight on this pivotal time in Colombian history as well as into its Guajiro setting, taking us inside the relationship between the Wayuu and non-indigenous cultures in the region. It offers an inside view of a culture being eroded by outside forces despite its determination to hold on to traditional life.

Symbolism abounds, as do searing human emotions, as the protagonist is torn between difficult, conflicting choices. Birds are indeed part of the story, serving as omens or as the embodiment of spirits, again echoing mythology. The film’s tone is perfect, and supplemented well by striking visuals, as it focuses on the family’s struggle to adhere to their traditional beliefs.

The visual settings are often starkly beautiful, with the Wayuu village seeming to exist in isolation on a wind-swept, dry plane that emphasizes it’s insular nature. Use of vibrant color in costumes contrasts with backgrounds nearly devoid of it. Other landscapes include the equally-windswept shoreline, and the green, high-mountain locale where Anibal has his coffee plantation.

BIRDS OF PASSAGE is a emotionally-gripping, visually-lush tale of Colombia history told as epic. It combines elements of Greek tragedy and crime family sagas where honor, vengeance and codes of conduct dominate, along with a human personal tale of longing to belong. The epic sweep of the story, spanning more that a decade, and the themes of omens and moral choices, brings to mind legends but the protagonist’s personal tale has a timeless, universal resonance.

BIRDS OF PASSAGE, in Spanish and Wayuu Guajiro language with English subtitles, opens Friday, March 15, at Landmarks’ Plaza Frontenac Cinema.

RATING: 4 1/2 out of 5 stars

 

FILM STARS DON’T DIE IN LIVERPOOL – Review

Annette Benning as Gloria Grahame and Jamie Bell as Peter Turner, in FILM STARS DON’T DIE IN LIVERPOOL. Courtesy of Sony Pictures Classics ©

FILM STARS DON’T DIE IN LIVERPOOL is based on Peter Turner’s memoir of the same name, about his relationship with 40s Hollywood star Gloria Grahame. If one is expecting a biopic on the Oscar-winning Grahame’s career, you won’t find it here. Instead, this is about love and friendship that grew out of a chance meeting and unlikely love affair between an older woman and younger man. Although the affair didn’t last, the fondness did.

Aspiring young actor Peter Turner (Jamie Bell) did not even know who Gloria Grahame was when he met her at a British boarding house the catered to actors. Grahame was appearing in a local theater and although middle-aged, still beautiful. When she asked the young actor to help her practice her dancing, he couldn’t say no. Peter was smitten by the older woman but quickly learned about her mercurial nature when he mentioned her age. Gloria’s reaction suggested she imagined herself as a perpetual 28-year-old and ran in terror from any hint she was aging. Yet, love quickly followed. After a move to New York, love quickly dissipated, through misunderstandings, jealousy and secrets.

Peter had already fallen for the charming sexy older woman when the landlady told him Gloria had once been a Hollywood star but was in decline. “A big name in black and white films, not doing too well in color,” as she put it.

So Peter was shocked to get a call years later, telling him that she had collapsed at a Lancaster theater where she was performing, refused medical treatment and asked only for him. Peter took her back to his parent’s modest working class home in Liverpool.

Gloria Grahame won an Oscar for her supporting role in THE BAD AND THE BEAUTIFUL, playing the type of role she often did, what Jamie Bell’s character describes as “a tart with a heart.” She might be best known to modern audiences for her role as Violet in IT’S A WONDERFUL LIFE. However, audiences should not expect to learn much about Grahame’s career in this film. The focus is on her later life and particularly her touching relationship with Turner. This is more Turner’s story, an ordinary guy who meets an extraordinary person, a more universal story in many ways while still unique to them.

 

Director Paul McGuigan’s previous films include LUCKY NUMBER SLEVIN and WICKER PARK. The screen adaptation was written by Matt Greenhalgh who wrote the scripts for CONTROL and NOWHERE BOY, and some of the strengths of those films as personal storytelling surface in this one.

Bell’s performance is what really makes this story. The gifted Jamie Bell is heart-wrenching as Peter, drawing out a complicated array of feelings about Gloria, an elusive soul with a complex history. Annette Benning, in what is more a supporting role, is likewise excellent as Gloria, an opaque person more focused on presenting a certain image, even to the point of self-delusion, than honesty, yet surprisingly charming and charismatic. Despite her flaws, Gloria is surprisingly sweet. She is charmed by Peter’s working class Liverpool home and wins the hearts of his family as she won his. When she needs some care, she wants to be with them. Benning’s performance is just as charming, a far more approachable character than the one she played in last year’s TWENTIETH CENTURY WOMEN. It is a bit surprising she did not garner much awards notice for the character but more surprising that Bell didn’t.

Hollywood does plenty of romances with an older man and younger woman but rarely the reverse. Even then, the older woman is often portrayed as foolish or worse, although older men are rarely shown that way, which makes this (true) story of younger man who truly loves an older woman all the more remarkable, and moving. The real Grahame did have a penchant for younger lovers, which the film touches on, something that society has long accepted for men but not women.

That role reversal gives the film a little feminist boost but that is not the film’s point nor even Grahame’s view. In the film, Grahame’s capacity for self-deceit is startling, and she is more a female Peter Pan (a common syndrome among men) than anything, if a remarkably touching one.

FILM STARS DON’T DIE IN LIVERPOOL might disappoint someone looking for a Gloria Grahame biopic but this film is a touching, sometimes funny, sometimes heart-breaking, tale about the power of friendship and love, even if it is based on the true story of a real Hollywood movie star.

RATING: 4 out of 5 stars