Director Ridley Scott returns to the world of ancient Rome with GLADIATOR II. GLADIATOR is an iconic film which made Joaquin Phoenix a star and starred Russell Crowe in this greatest role but this enduringly popular epic didn’t particularly feel like it needed a sequel as it felt pretty complete. Yet here we are. Actually, GLADIATOR II is a combination of sequel and remake, and has an excellent cast including Paul Mescal, Pedro Pascal, and Denzel Washington. Paul Mescal star as Lucius, whose story both reflects and connects to Russell Crowe’s Maximus’ tale. Two members of the original cast return, Connie Nielsen as Lucilla and Derek Jacobi as Gracchus, and while Jacobi’s screen time is brief, Nielsen plays a major role. Yet despite a fiery, Oscar-worthy performance by Denzel Washington and good work by the rest of the cast, plentiful gladiator fight scenes, and impressive sets, costumes and visual effects, the sequel/remake does not have the same energy and narrative drive as the original.
Taking place some years after the original, we return to a Roman empire ruled by a pair of red-headed, debauched brother Caesars, Emperor Geta (Joseph Quinn) and his more blood-thirsty but less rational brother Emperor Caracalla (Fred Hechinger). Meanwhile, in a distant land Lucius (Paul Mescal) and his warrior wife are preparing to defend their city from a Roman army led by General Marcus Acacius (Pedro Pascal). Things don’t go well, and the wife ends up dead and Lucius ends up as a galley slave and then a gladiator, owned by wealthy former gladiator Macrinus (Denzel Washington). But when Macrinus brings his prize gladiator to Rome, we learn this Lucius is the grown-up son of the daughter of Marcus Aurelius, Lucilla (Connie Nielsen) who, as it happens, is married to Pedro Pascal’s honorable General Acacius, whom Lucius has sworn to kill to avenge his wife.
That is no spoiler as it the film’s synopsis and not hard to guess anyway. The film embarks on a tale of intrigue, ambition, revenge and plentiful of bloody spectacle set in ancient Rome which parallels the original in many ways. Paul Mescal is a gifted actor but doesn’t have the big screen charisma of Russell Crowe. The twin emperors are appropriately awful, and Joseph Quinn and Fred Hechinger are entertainingly crazy, together and separately, but they are not the brainy plotters that Joaquin Phoenix’s emperor was. The true source of evil intriguing is more diffuse and concealed until well into the story. Not everyone is as good or bad as they seem at the film’s start, making this epic more twisty than a straightforward heroic tale like the original.
The most striking performances are Connie Nielsen’s, as the older Lucilla, harkening back to her earlier character and moving this new tale forward, and the flashy, fabulous one by Denzel Washington, in a part that starts out echoing Oliver Reed’s memorable turn as the gladiator-turned-entrepreneur, but taking his character much further. Washington is irresistible every time he’s on screen, with a knowing, sly humor, and exuding style and sophistication. It is Denzel Washington’s best performance in years in a rich role he can really mine for all its complexities. Watching him work is perhaps the major delight of this film.
The problem is that the original story was pretty complete, and although writers Peter Craig and David Scarpa did come up with a clever way to continue that tale, while also recapping it, it never feels like a necessary story. The director may have recognized that as the film has several clips of the original, often as Paul Mescal repeats scenes Russell Crowe did first. While it reminds the audience of the beloved original, it also takes out of this story. It is this choice, plus the weaker, less straight-forward story, that limits the film, despite the best efforts of the cast and the spectacular effects and lush visual world it created.
But if you are just here for the spectacle, GLADIATOR delivers on that, in a big way. The recreation of Rome is eye-popping, with a mix of physical sets and visual effects, and there is plenty of bloody battle and gladiator fights to please action fans and lavish costume drama gorgeousness to delight those fans. Stunt work is great and the CGI creatures are impressive.
On the downside, the film plays very fast and loose with real history, even more so than the original, with an ending so far from the facts that is rivals INGLORIOUS BASTERDS’ Nazi alt-history fantasy. I fear for any poorly-educated young person who might take fantastical yarn this for history.
Still, while revisiting the world of Ridley Scott’s GLADIATOR is enjoyable, there is little in GLADIATOR II that adds much to that, beyond the visual delights and Denzel Washington’s crazy good performance.
GLADIATOR opens Friday, Nov. 22, in theaters.
RATING: 2.5 out of 4 stars
