AMERICA – Review

(L-R) Yotam (Ofri Biterman), Iris (Oshrat Ingedashet) and Eli (Michael Moshonov) in AMERICA. Photo credit: Beta Cinema. Courtesy of Menemsha Films

AMERICA, despite the title, is not set in the U.S. nor is it about America, Instead, it is a deeply human, moving, emotionally complex, intelligent Israeli drama an Israeli man who has lived in America for decades but returns after the death of his long-estranged father, to deal with the estate, and reconnects with some people from his past. Human relationships, and a different take on a love triangle, as the center of the fine drama/romance AMERICA, from the director of the international hit THE CAKEMAKER. Israeli writer/director Ofir Raul Graizer helmed both that excellent German drama and this new this Hebrew-language drama/romance, which feels like a kind of sequel in its similar emotional, poignant style.

AMERICA centers on an Israeli-born man, Eli (Michael Moshonov), who has lived in Chicago for ten years, since leaving Israel as a teenager. A one-time swimming champion, Eli now has made a life for himself in America as a swimming instructor, with no intention to even return to Israel, even changing his name to leave his past behind, But Eli is reluctantly compelled to return to Israel, in order to sort out the estate of his late father, from whom he was long estranged. The swimmer only intends to stay long enough to sell his father’s house in Tel Aviv and therefore settle the estate.

At his old house, Eli runs into an old neighbor by chance, Moti (Moni Moshonov), who is very glad to see him. The swimming instruction is pleased as well to see Moti, who was kind and even a kind of father-figure to Eli as a boy after his mother died and the boy struggled in his difficult relationship with his police chief father. The chance meeting leads Eli to reconnect with Moti’s son Yotam (Ofri Biterman), a childhood friend who shared his love of swimming, and to meet his friend’s fiancee, Iris (Oshrat Ingedashet), who has a flower shop in Jaffa which she runs with Yotam. Yotam no longer swims but helps Iris run her flower shop. Iris is estranged from her strict Moroccan family, much like Eli is estranged from his.

We catch a frisson of attraction between Eli and Iris but of course neither acts on it because of Yotam. A tragic accident changes everybody’s plans, creating a complicated situation for everyone.

Director Graizer uses beautiful, evocative locations and settings to deepen scenes and add to character. The flower shop that Iris runs is crowded with colorful blooms and green foliage, offering a lush, even sensual, setting around which much of the drama unfolds. It seems to symbolize life, and the setting particularly wrapping Iris in beauty and vibrant life. In one scene, the old friends drive out to remote location, a favorite swimming hole of their youth, and take a long trek through difficult, dry terrain to arrive at a beautiful waterfall and idyllic pool of water beneath it.

Like THE CAKEMAKER, the story is layered with details that gives it the feel of reality, and the people in it are complex in the way real people are. That depth of detail and layered character makes the film intriguing as well as unpredictable. We can guess some things that happen but we never know when some new twist, some surprise – good or bad – is lurking around the next corner. The sense of reality unfolding gives the film a kind of tension but also makes the characters wholly believable. We can’t resist being drawn into the lives of these interesting people.

The fine script is further boosted by an excellent cast, who create people we like, even if we don’t understand everything about them. As the story unfolds, dilemmas arise and complex ethical choices face them. The characters are forced to make choices, where the right path isn’t always clear.

This excellent drama is a follow-up, in a way, to the director’s previous one, THE CAKE MAKER, a hit film that also had complicated people in complicated situations with a romantic theme, but people we pull for. The script in both these films is superb, as is the work of the cast. This is the kind of intelligent, human storytelling fans of serious drama long for, yet AMERICA, like its predecessor, also delivers as an entertaining film.

AMERICA opened Friday, July 4, in select theaters and expands to additional cities on Friday, August 2.

RATING: 4 out of 4 stars

MATCHMAKING – St. Louis Jewish Film Festival Review

Nechama (Liana Ayoun, at center right) meets a not-too-promising date, in the romantic comedy MATCHMAKING. Courtesy of Israeli Films

MATCHMAKING, one of the best comedies at this year’s St. Louis Jewish Film Festival, is a romantic comedy about a young Orthodox Jewish who seems to have everything a family could want in a match – good family, good grades, good looks – but who is pining for a girl who, on paper, does not match up.

Yeshiva student Moti Bernstein (Amit Rahav) is a good student and obedient son from a respected Israeli Ashkenazi Jewish family who has reached the age to start looking for a wife. Moti is a catch who has it all – handsome, smart, tall, from a good Ashkenazi family – everything any matchmaker or Orthodox family would want. As an A-list candidate in the books of Orthodox matchmaking, Moti is a guy who should have his pick of any girl he wants for a bride. So what’s the problem? While the matchmaker is busily arranging dates to match this A-list find, Moti is secretly falling for his sister’s best friend, a girl no matchmaker would pick for this top prospect. But who decides it is a perfect match?

The delightfully funny, charming Israeli romantic comedy MATCHMAKING poses just this dilemma, where the heart and the head part ways in the matter of marriage, while giving us insights into the world of Orthodox Jewish matchmaking. MATCHMAKING leans into the comedy, with wonderful performances and a surprising amount of slapstick in this light Jewish take on Romeo and Juliet. The Israeli romantic comedy, directed and co-written by Erez Tadmor, has been a hit at numerous Jewish film festivals and a smash in Israel, with its charming performances, laugh-out-loud moments, and thoughtful look at the practice of matchmaking in the Jewish Orthodox community.

The matchmaker looks at their lists of people seeking a marriage and match people up according to family background and standing, the prospect’s personal characteristics and interests, and offers those prospective brides and grooms to their clients, with the approval of families. The couple then meet in a short series of dates, where they ask each other questions and get a sense of the potential spouse. But ultimately, it is the couple who decide. If he thinks she’s his match, he proposes and the wedding is on. If either thinks it won’t work, he or she can turn down further dates.

Eager to please his parents and looking forward to the marriage that will start his adult life, Moti dutifully goes on his arranged dates with some beautiful young women, including a gorgeous American Jewish young woman from a rich family. She is a rare catch, and marriage to her would mean his future would be secured and comfortable, and he would be free spending his time as a scholar, studying the Torah, the highest, most prestigious ambition in his community. Yet Moti’s eye is repeatedly drawn to his younger sister’s friend Nechama (Liana Ayoun).

He’s known this girl practically all his life, yet now when he is supposed to be deciding between one perfect girl and another, he keeps thinking about her instead of the prospects he’s dating. She’s pretty, she’s smart, she’s serious – all things Moti admires – but she’s also half-Sephardic, with a mother from North Africa, which in Israeli Orthodox society means her family is nowhere near his equal. She’s on no one’s A-list, and the only Ashkenazi she could hope to be paired with is Moti’s short, asthmatic, socially-awkward schoolmate . It’s a mismatch in the matchmakers’ books.

Moti is a dutiful son and tries to focus on his obligation to pick a spouse that pleases his family, but what about his own heart? Will he forget her with time, as others tell him, especially if his choice lands him in the lap of luxury? What should Moti do – and what’s more, what can he do?

The cast is charming and the love-and-marriage conundrum allows the film to gently explore the limits of matchmaking, where family standing and parents’ preferences rather than the young person’s feelings that determine what is a perfect match. The film gently discusses the pros and cons of the system – it’s success in pairing like to like backgrounds for a solid marriage versus what can go wrong if couple’s families are too different.

As Moti, Amit Rahav gives a strong performance as the appealingly conflicted young man, trying to be the perfect son but also aware of his growing feelings. As Nechama, Liana Ayoun is appealing as well, but someone who is more practical and even skeptical, and looks at the situation with less emotion and with a wary eye on Moti’s feelings, wondering if they might fade. Even if they both want this match – by no means clear – what would be the price be for their families?

As the two young people and their families dance around the problem, MATCHMAKING throws in little comic relief bits as we explore the serious side of the issue. Some of that comic relief comes from one of Moti’s classmates, a shy, awkward guy with asthma who is not on anyone’s A list despite his good family. While Moti goes on his dates, Nechama goes on a few of her own, with no winning prospects but some comic moments. On the other hand, a male matchmaker, Baruch (a wonderful warm and funny Maor Schwietzer), who never married and still lives at the yeshiva, revisits his own tragic romantic history.

MATCHMAKING weaves all these elements – thoughtful, humorous, romantic – into a wonderful, funny and warm tapestry that leads to insights on the challenges of love and marriage.

MATCHMAKING, in Hebrew with English subtitles, plays the St. Louis Jewish Film Festival on Sunday, Apr. 14 at 3:30pm at the B&B West Olive Cinema in Creve Coeur.

“Queens: Season 1” – TV Series Review

The cast of the Israeli TV series “Queens,” Season 1, on MHz Choice

The extent to which you may enjoy the Israeli TV series “Queens: Season 1″ depends on expectations from its Mafia-esque premise. All the men in one of the country’s crime families are killed at the beginning, except for one overlooked child, who may or may not have seen the shooter(s). The wives and daughters find themselves on the brink of losing all the wealth and power their husbands oversaw when rival families swoop in claiming debts to be honored and businesses to snatch from them. The women decide to defend their turf and family honor by trying to do what their men had done in running their illegal businesses.

For American audiences, the first analog that comes to mind is “The Sopranos,” with infighting among competing families and ambitious underlings. The closer comparison might be with “Queen of the South,” which some strong, determined women struggle to become drug cartel bosses against a variety of male obstacles. To get into this one, forget about those. The tone is significantly tamer.

First of all, “Queens” is considerably less violent and sexy than either of those domestic counterparts. There’s plenty of menace and moments of brutality but well short of the others’ body counts or displays of carnage. The other is that these women are truly feckless at succeeding their husbands, sons and brothers, resulting in their taking far more punishment than they dish out. For about half of the 11 hour-long episodes, they’re getting pummeled and losing territory, without getting their act together. There’s suspense in learning who was behind the mass execution of their men, and whether that surviving child will be another target or the key to ID-ing the perp(s). Suspects abound. Fortunately, the women’s lot shows more signs of hope emerging in the second half of the season.

Among the protagonists we meet a diverse group of characters contributing fine performances, and a handful of particularly dastardly villains to create the requisite tensions. The matriarchal widow, Dori (Rita – the Israeli actress goes by that one name, like Cher), is rather strident and overbearing in her desperation to assert control and normalize their situation. Her daughter, Lizi (Dana Igvy), seems like the only one tough and focused enough to get them back to an acceptable position among their underworld colleagues and rivals. Others also have interesting story arcs, including a few surprises that maintain viewers’ interest.

So once you gear down for less adrenaline boosting than our series mentioned above, you wind up with an action and character drama that works pretty well. The bad news is that Season 1 ends on several cliffhanger plot points of unanswered questions and unresolved issues. The good news is that Season 2 already has aired in Israel, and will be released for streaming here within the next few months.

“Queens: Season 1,” mostly in Hebrew with English subtitles, streams on MHz Choice starting on Sept. 19.

RATING: 1.5 out of 4 stars

Israeli TV series “Queens” on MHz Choice

GOLDA – Review

Helen Mirren as Golda Meir and Liev Schreiber as Henry Kissinger, in Bleecker Street/ShivHans Pictures’ GOLDA Photo credit: Sean Gleason, Courtesy of Bleecker Street/ShivHans Pictures

Helen Mirren portrays Golda Meir, Israel’s first women prime minister, during the 1973 Yom Kippur War, in GOLDA. Internationally, Golda Meir is known as the “Iron Lady of Israel” and is an admired figure but she is more controversial in her home country of Israel. In the British historical drama GOLDA, Israeli-American director Guy Nativ and British scriptwriter Nicholas Martin aim to offer a fresh look at Golda Meir by focusing on her during the Yom Kippur War, when Israel found itself facing two invading armies, from Egypt in the Sinai and Syria in the Golan Heights.

Mirren plays Golda Meir in heavy makeup and prosthetics, transforming her appearenceappearance to more closely resemble the much-photographed Golda Meir and allow director Nativ to more easily include generous use of archival footage and even insert Mirren into some of those scenes. Mirren’s physical transformation is impressive enough to draw gasps, but some have criticized the makeup as restricting her performance, while others, including this writer, feel that Mirren still delivers an affecting performance, which some have called Oscar-worthy.

Adding to the controversy is that Helen Mirren is not Jewish, raising objections to “Jew face” casting. However, Israeli-American director Guy Nativ sought her out for this role, after she was first suggested by Golda Meir’s grandson Gideon Meir, who was a consultant on the drama. Mirren’s carefully-researched, restrained performance gives little room for criticism, and having an Israeli-born director, plus a strong supporting cast with many Israel and Jewish actors, also goes a ways towards softening the issue.

GOLDA is neither a true biopic nor is it a battlefield war epic, and people expecting either will be disappointed. Instead, it is a engrossing and tense, ticking-clock drama in which Helen Mirren gives a taut portrayal of Golda Meir during the Yom Kippur War, which was an existential threat to Israel but ultimately led to the peace accord and recognition with Egypt.

Golda Meir was an Israeli national hero when she was chosen as Israel’s first (and so far only) woman prime minister but she was considered an interim choice because the sides could not agree on a choice. By any standard, Meir had a remarkable life, from her childhood in Ukraine under the Russia empire, to her family’s emigration to Milwaukee, to her decision as a young woman to move to Israel and fight in its war for independence. But GOLDA neither a full biography nor is it a full examination of the events of the Yom Yippur War, but a hybrid of the two that focuses on Golda Meir’s experience of that war.

The 1973 Yom Kippur War came not long after the Six Days War, where that quick victory left Israeli generals feeling overconfident. GOLDA opens with a brief montage of archival images and video to recap some early Israeli history, and then moves on to a post-Yom Kippur War hearing, where Prime Minister Golda Meir (Mirren) is being questioned by the Agranat commission about controversial decisions made during the war, which had high casualties on all sides.

The commission is used as a framing devise for Golda to tell her story of the war, from her perspective. That retelling begins with Prime Minister Golda Meir getting a report from the head of Mossad, Zvi Zamir (Israeli actor Rotem Keinan), about a source warning of an imminent attack by both Egypt and Syria, Israel’s neighbors to the south and north, a warning that comes in October just as Yom Kippur is approaching.

Unfortunately, this same Mossad source has warned of an attack earlier in the year, which never took place. so Meir knows defense minister Moshe Dayan (Israeli actor Rami Heuberger) will be skeptical. When she meets with her military advisors, all men, they show her little respect, barely remembering to stand for her as they would for any prime minister. Overconfident after the success of the Six Day War, the generals mostly dismiss the idea of an attack during the high holy days, even though Meir warns is a perfect time for one. Military intelligence head Eli Zeira (Israeli actor Dvir Benedek) assures her that their secret listening system will warn them of any attack well in advance, even despite the holiday. He’s wrong.

The film is packed with famous figures of Israeli history, and the cast includes Israel stars Lior Ashkenazi as General David “Dado” Elazar and Ohad Knoller as a young Ariel Sharon, while Liev Schreiber plays U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger. The acting is strong but nuanced throughout, but the drama is more emotionally restrained than explosive.

While billed as a “political thriller,” GOLDA lacks the pulse-pounding pace of a thriller. Instead, it is more a tense, involving drama, as we follow Golda Meir closely as she copes with war on two fronts, a team of over-confident all-male generals who are shocked when their forces are at first overwhelmed, and her own anguish over war casualties. The sexism of the era is present, as the men who are supposed to serve her as prime minister often fail to even stand when she enters, as they have done for every other prime minister, but the film does not dwell on this. Instead the focus is on Golda Meir’s skill as a leader and decision-maker, despite her lack of military experience, and her anguish at the war’s loss of life, losses she records day by day in a notebook.

Mirren’s Golda is a chain-smoking, flinty character with a sharp political mind and cunning skill in manipulating the men who surround her and anticipating the plans of her enemies. At the time, Golda Meir was 76 years old and suffering from cancer, something depicted in a few scenes. She was in poor physical shape, so travel to the war zone was largely not possible, which means this war-time story largely takes place in Golda Meir’s office, the hallways and bunkers where Meir and her generals discussed military actions and listened to radio reports from the two fronts.

Watching the grandmotherly figure navigate the politics of the strong male personalities in the room with a flinty strength, while making decisive, smart strategic military decisions despite her lack of soldierly training, is inspiring, and one of the highlights of Mirren’s performance. Away from the meetings, we see the more haunted and personal side of Golda.

Among the film’s best moments are when Golda Meir charms and cajoles Kissinger into providing aid for Israel, despite the Watergate scandal unfolding at the same time. They talk by phone and then Kissinger visits Israel to talk in-person with Meir. Meir feeds Kissinger borscht, and then gets to work. Schreiber’s Kissinger cautions her ” “Madame Prime Minister, in terms of our work together, I think it is important to remember I am first an American, second I am Secretary of State, and third I am a Jew.” Golda Meir replies “You forget that in Israel, we read from left to right.” It provides a rare moment of lightness and humor in the drama.

The carefully-researched film recreates the period look. While much of the drama takes place in smoke-filled rooms and half-lit hallways, Nativ captures the horror of the war with clips of archival footage and actual audience recordings of battlefield exchanges. There is also frequent use of other archival footage, including some with the real Golda Meir, and some where Mirren is inserted into the archival image. The film works hard to accurately recreate Golda Meir’s clothes, appearance and smoking, as well as the look of her office and other spaces where the story unfolds, with the help of Meir’s grandson Gideon as a consultant.

The personal side of Meir comes out mostly in her scenes with her personal assistant and friend, Lou Kaddar (French actress Camille Cottin), which are warm and sometimes depict her defiance or moments of doubt. The soundtrack is tense, often with a percussive character and metallic, strident bells. The film concludes with the perfect choice of Leonard Cohen’s song “Who By Fire,” which he wrote after visiting Israeli troops during this war.

GOLDA, in English and Hebrew with English subtitles, opens Friday, Aug. 25, at Landmark’s Plaza Frontenac Cinema and other theaters nationally.

RATING: 3 out of 4 stars

GREENER PASTURES – SLJFF Review

Shlomo Bar-Aba as Dov in the Israeli comedy GREENER PASTURES. one of films at the virtual 2022 St. Louis Jewish Film Festival. Courtesy of Israeli Films

In the delightfully funny Israeli comedy GREENER PASTURES, a retiree named Dov (Shlomo Bar-Aba) feels like he has been put out to pasture, and not a greener one. The widower grandpa in his 70s is dismayed that his daughter, who lives out of town, has moved him to a retirement home and out of the house he loves. A retired postal worker, he has been done out of his pension following privatization.

GREENER PASTURES is part of the 2022 St. Louis Jewish Film Festival, which is virtual again this year, meaning all films can be streamed through the festival website through March 13. For tickets and more information, visit their website https://jccstl.com/arts-ideas/st-louis-jewish-film-festival.

Sure, the retirement community he’s in is nice but it’s not home and he hates it. even though he has only been there one week. Dov is determined to find a way to buy his house back, intending to move back and stay there until he dies. Dov’s grandson shows little interest but his girlfriend Dana (Joy Rieger), a lawyer, is a more sympathetic ear.

Enter the grass – that is the medicinal marjuana that all Israeli seniors are eligible to get through prescription. While pot is illegal in Israel, it is easily available to its senior citizens. Dov isn’t interested in smoking it, but he recognizes selling it could help him raise the funds to buy back his old house. A colorful old pothead, now in a wheelchair, Yehuda (Doval’e Glickman), who lives nearby, helps with getting the business rolling. A friend of Dana helps as well. Soon, Dov is well on the way to funding his plan to buy back his home, if he can just stay out of jail.

Cannabis, a nosy cop and a pair of sinister gangsters are all part of this tale of a rebellious retiree who is not content to accept what fate has dealt him.

This Israeli comedy is superbly acted, with an ensemble cast on their toes with the comic timing. Assaf Abiri and Matan Guggenheim co-wrote and co-directed this sly comedy, which has been nominated for 12 Ophirs, Israel’s version of an Oscar. Crackling comic dialog blends humor with family drama, thriller and even romance aspects, along with some social commentary, and topped by a clever twist at the end. It is a big plus that seniors are treated with respect in this comedy, as smart resourceful people and not objects of fun themselves. GREENER PASTURES uses its humor to tackles the issue of cannabis in modern Israel, as well as attitudes toward senior citizens, the impact of privatization, and even government corruption, all done with the satiric humor. GREENER PASTURES also spotlights friendships across generations and finding a second chance late in life.

The cast really makes this film. Shlomo Bar-Aba as Dov is delightfully droll, deadpanning in scene after scene. His slightly sarcastic delivery is particularly funny against the broad humor of Doval’e Glickman as Yehuda, a older wheelchair-bound rock star wannabee, whose slangy speech and kingpin posing have Dov rolling his eyes and us guffawing. By contrast the warmth that grows between Dov and his grandson’s girlfriend Dana, played with charm by Joy Rieger, is appealing, and a dash of romance is added as Dov’s relationship with the retirement home’s doctor evolves beyond the professional.

While things go smoothly in the pot biz at first, and Dov is on the way to having enough to buy back his house, a bumpier ride is in the offing when a cop starts sniffing around and a powerful gangster enters the picture. The film develops a little thriller side as the story progresses and Dov and his friends find themselves in a tight spot.

The ending puts a perfect spin on the tale. GREENER PASTURES is film filled with comic delights, snappy dialog, fine performances, with some thought-provoking subtext, and nice final twist to cap it all, making it one enjoyable film. GREENER PASTURES, in Hebrew with English subtitles, is available to stream as part of the 2022 St. Louis Jewish Film Festival through Mar. 13. For tickets and more information, visit their website https://jccstl.com/arts-ideas/st-louis-jewish-film-festival.

NEIGHBOURS – SLIFF Review

Serhed Khalil as Sero, in the Swiss-Kurdish satiric dramedy NEIGHBOURS, playing at the 2021 St. Louis International Film Festival.
Courtesy of Cinema St. Louis

There is a lot of humor and sly satire in this child-centric tale looking at the roots of hate in the Middle East. Swiss-Kurdish director Mano Khalil’s NEIGHBOURS (“Nachbarn”) is a Swiss film set in Syria 40 years ago, in a small village where Kurdish and Jewish families are neighbors. Actually, at this point, there is only one Jewish family left in the village, although there used to be more, a change due to the increasingly hostile policies of the ruling Syrian Baathist party. Partly based on the director’s bittersweet memories of his own childhood, he captures the joys and heartbreak of childhood and also explores the absurdity of bigotry, antisemitism, and conflict, through the lens of those childhood memories.

“Neighbours” begins with a framing device in the present, where a Kurdish extended family is living in a refugee camp after fleeing the violence in Syria, where they are waiting to hear from someone they reached out to in Switzerland. The reply comes in the form of a picture and a request that the family patriarch (Sherzad Abdulla) identify the people in it. It is not a photo, but a child’s drawing, a drawing that sparks childhood memories of 40 years ago.

The flashback takes us back 40 years to childhood memories, when the middle-aged man was a seven-year-old boy in a small mostly Kurdish village on the Turkish-Syrian border. Starting with the subject of the drawing, little Sero (Serhed Khalil) and his beloved uncle Aram (Ismail Zagros) prank the Turkish border guards by releasing balloons in the Kurdish national colors. It is something sure to enrage the Turkish guards but it otherwise a harmless thumbing their noses at a border that divided Kurdish families, including theirs, and left them outsiders in both countries on either side.

Uncle Aram is Sero’s father’s younger brother, a fun-loving, mischievous young man whom the seven-year-old adores. In their little Kurdish village on the border, everyone knows everyone, and everyone gets along. While the kids tear playfully around the village, the village elders watch and shake their heads about “kids these days.” Sero’s neighbors are a Jewish family who his family has known, and been friendly with, for years. Sero helps them on the Sabbath by lighting the lamps and stove, something his uncle Aram used to do too when he was younger. Once, there were several Jewish families in the village but they are now the only ones left, as others have fled. They would like to leave too but now the Baathist government won’t recognize Jews as citizens or give them passports.

The village is waiting for the arrival of two things: the electrical power and the new teacher. The power lines have been in place for some time and village homes have been wired for electricity but no power has arrived yet. Sero particularly longs for electricity so he can watch cartoons like the kids in the city do – and he continually pesters his parents for a TV.

Still, there is a great deal of humor and the charm in this childhood world of play, although there is a serious side to this dramedy, and tragic events eventually strike. A lot of that charm comes from young Serhed Khalil as Sero, a sweet-faced boy full of mischief and playful joy. But all the cast bring warmth and appeal to their roles, particularly Ismail Zagros as Aram, and Uygurlar Derya as Hannah, the daughter of the Jewish family. The Jewish parents would like to escape Syria, and especially want to get their daughter out, but Hannah does not want to leave her home behind, and particularly her childhood friend Aram.

While there is still no electricity, a new teacher, Wahid Hanouf (Jalal Al Tawil), does arrive. The teacher is a rigid true-believer in Assad’s Baathist party, whose ideology is a mix of communist and pan-Arab ideas, without really being either, but with a big dose of antisemitism. The teacher thinks instilling these antisemitic ideas are as much his job as teaching reading and writing. One of the first things the teacher does is insist that the children only speak Arabic in class and at home. Sero does not much like school anyway but he is really at a loss now when the teacher insists that everyone speak only Arabic, which he neither speaks nor understands. When the teacher starts repeating old antisemitic myths, Sero doesn’t believe what the teacher says about his kindly neighbors, but other children buy in to the lies and other evilness.

The teacher is the outsider who brings hate and antisemitism to the village, and disrupts their quiet lives. He is helped along by a local man who is the village’s sole Baath party member, a membership that gave him a house and a job despite his illiteracy. These two are the primary villains of this child’s-eye-view story but other representatives of the authoritarian government in the story, such as the border guards and bureaucrats, also bring either danger or a callous indifference and corruption. The film has a powerful, satiric punch in its chilling depiction of how hatred is taught, as the teacher indoctrinates his charges in antisemitic ideas that include the old “blood libel.” Sero’s parents and grandparents, and his Jewish neighbors, are the counterbalance to this, with their long friendship and willingness to help each other.

NEIGHBOURS is both a touching, warm human tale laced with humor and childhood appeal, and a pointed satiric look at the roots of hate, not just in Syria. NEIGHBOURS, in Kurdish, Arabic, English and Hebrew with English subtitles, plays at SLIFF on Tuesday, Nov. 9 ,at 7pm and Wednesday, Nov. 10, at 4pm

RATING: 3 out of 4 stars

INCITEMENT – Review

Yehuda Nahari Halevi as Yigal Amir, in the tense Israeli historical political thriller INCITEMENT. Photo credit: Zachary Martin Courtesy of Greenwich

What makes a person move from extremist views to violence is the subject of Yaron Zilberman’s INCITEMENT. Specifically, Zilberman’s unsettling drama/thriller traces the journey of the young far-right Jewish man who assassinated Israel’s Prime Minsiter Yitzak Rabin, an event that altered the direction of Israeli politics and put an end to the Oslo peace accord and its prospect for peace with the Palestinians.

This gripping, harrowing thriller earned an Ophir, the Israeli equivalent of the Oscar, for best film as well as one for best casting, and a nomination for the tour-de-force performance of its young lead actor. Despite the awards, the historical drama has sparked controversy in Israel.

When President Bill Clinton helped broker a peace deal between Rabin and Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat with the Oslo accord, many in Israel celebrated the prospect of a solution to the intractable Israeli-Palestinian conflict. But vocal opposition from extremists among both Palestinians and Israelis quickly surfaced. Still, no one expected an assassination of the Israeli prime minister by an ultra-Orthodox Jewish man.

Yigal Amir (Yehuda Nahari Halevi) is already near the far end of conservative Israelis when the peace deal is announced. His Orthodox family generally share his conservative views, although maybe not the degree to which his political views occupy his thoughts.

Watching Yigal’s transformation up close like this is a disturbing experience but director Zilberman uses our discomfort to make a critical point about how violent extremists are born. Early on, Yigal attends protest rallies opposing the peace accord, but then seems on the verge of joining in when rally turns violent. Still, when a policeman starts to arrest him, he begs to be let go, pleading that it will ruin his career as a law student and that he is about to be married and his fiancee will dump him if she finds out. The emotional plea works and the policeman lets him go.

It is true that Yigal is studying law but he exaggerated his romantic situation. He and Nava (Daniella Kertesz) are discussing marriage, but no wedding is in the offing. There is a family complication, as Nava is an Ashkenazi Jew, while his family are and his family are Sephardic Jews from Yemen. There are hints of prejudice against the Sephardi in Israeli society generally, and Yigal’s mother is filled with resentment towards the Ashkenazim Jewish majority who dominate Israeli society. She cautions her son that Nava’s Eastern European-derived family will never accept him, re-inforcing his sense of being an outsider.

However, the incitement in the title comes more from heated political climate and the incendiary speeches of far-right rabbis and other leaders. When Yigal and his more radical friends like Shlomo Amir (Amitay Yaish Benuosilio) begin to talk about assassination, Yigal seeks moral approval from like-minded extreme right rabbis. When Yigal makes inquiries, clocking his question as a philosophical one, there is no shortage of heated talk. Some are willing to provide that needed rationale, although the argument is phrased indirectly and the rabbis may not be aware of what a powder keg Yigal is, or their role as the match.

It is a chilling film, a true story that unfolds like a taut thriller, one that picks up speed and terror as Yigal and his radical friends plunge into the realm of terrorism. Yehuda Nahari Halevi is riveting and terrifying as Yigal as we see him slip under the surface of extremism, stepping from protest to violence. The performance is stunning, as we watch the character become increasingly un-moored from his more mainstream friends and ordinary life, drawn in by speeches of extremist leaders and rabbis.

INCITEMENT gives us a cautionary tale on the making of an assassin, and a lesson in the toxic power of incendiary rhetoric, a lesson all societies should heed. INCITEMENT, in Hebrew with English subtitles, opens Friday, February 21, at Landmark’s Plaza Frontenac Cinema.

RATING: 3 1/2 out of 4 stars

Tribeca 2011 Review: RABIES

There is a fundamental flaw with RABIES that will unfortunately hold it back from the major success it could have been. I am of course talking about the fact the film is in Hebrew. Because people hate to read at the movies, it will not get a wide theatrical release (unless it gets the HIGH TENSION treatment) and some people will skip it when it hits video & VOD. It’s a real shame because RABIES is one of the best and most inventive horror films I have seen in a while.

A quick summary makes the film seem like an overly clichéd backwoods slasher but its brilliant execution reveals that it is so much more. The film opens with a girl caught in a trap while her brother attempts to rescue her, a group of young tennis players lost in the woods and a kindhearted park ranger doing a routine inspection with his trusty dog. A little later we meet two cops; one is quite crooked while the other is dealing with personal issues. We are even introduced to a psychotic killer that doesn’t wear a mask or have any supernatural abilities; he’s just a man with a large knife. This all sounds pretty standard, right?

What if I told you the psycho killer doesn’t actually kill anyone yet the body count at the end of the film still meets the typical slasher quota? Shortly after we are introduced to the killer, he gets knocked out. Confusion, jealousy, mistrust, poor judgment, and several accidents put the potential victims at odds with each other. Their secluded surroundings full of bear traps, land mines, and other dangerous obstacles only add to the mayhem.

RABIES plays with genre conventions and does it well. The acting is surprisingly strong across the board and really brings you into the story. Unfortunately, there were a few times where I was unable to read the subtitles because this is by far one of the brightest horror movie you will ever see. The entire film takes place over the course of a sunny afternoon and many of the characters are dressed entirely in white. The fact they were able to make such a suspenseful horror film in broad daylight shows you how talented the writer/director duo of Aharon Keshales and Navot Papushado really are. Unfortunately it made the pale yellow subtitles hard to read at times but I never lost my place in the film nor lost any interest in the characters. In fact, I believe you can watch the entire film sans subtitles and still enjoy it but then you’d miss out on some of the brutally clever dialogue. There are some hilarious jokes and lines that elevate the film to a very darkly humorous level. The pacing and cinematography are equally great.

I really loved how the film plays out in seemingly real time and that the filmmakers are not afraid to have key moments occur off screen. The scenes not shown are largely unnecessary and keeping them out keeps the film fast-paced. It even adds to the suspense at times. This approach to the story really works well throughout but I was surprised to see that it ends in the same style. While each storyline is interconnected, there was no grand finale where everything comes together. Instead each story has it’s own ending. This is where my one real big problem with the film lies. I actually liked each individual ending and wouldn’t change anything about them. However, I feel they made a huge mistake in the order of the endings. There is one very short scene that I believe should have come a little later in the film.  (To keep this review spoiler free, I will not describe the scene but will gladly tell you if you message me after you see it.) It would have worked far better as the final resolution. They could keep everything else exactly the same, including the tag within the credits, but just change the order of the finale. I know it is a very minor complaint but it is really the only thing that bothered me about the film.

I highly recommend you check out RABIES for yourself. And from now until May 1st, you can watch it online for free. Just go to the Tribeca Film Festival online streaming room at http://www.tribecafilm.com/tribecaonline/streaming-room/ and reserve a seat for the next free online screening. If you don’t get a chance to watch it now, be sure to keep an eye out for it. The film has the distinction of being Israel’s first ever horror film and it has set the bar absurdly high.

Jerry Cavallaro  – www.StuckLikeChuck.com