I PLAY ROCKY – Review

The making of a motion picture is often referred to as a “crapshoot”, as in a huuuge gamble. On the rare occasion when it pays off, really pays off, the reasons for its success are part of its critical dissection. The marketing and “star power’ often play a factor, although its timing is a tricky element. A script can be carried by the “cultural zeitgeist”, A certain “something in the air” that “rides a wave”. Most recently, many have speculated that this may account for the unexpected box office numbers and longevity of OBSSESSION and YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING. This isn’t anything new, as we can go back to FATAL ATTRACTION in 1987, and another eleven years to the subject of this new release. It concerns a beloved, iconic movie (one I saw during its original theatrical run…yikes, I’m ancient) about a “lil’ guy” who defied the odds. It turns out that the story of its creation is also an underdog story. Oh, and this single “imperative’ from the screenwriter almost “K.O’d” the whole project. That demand was simple: I PLAY ROCKY. Yo…

In the early 1970s, we observe an audition that goes “south” for struggling actor Sylvester Stallone (Anthony Ippolito). After a quick “thank you”, he trudges through the filthy streets to his even filthier “flop house room”. Sly has acting aspirations, but he can’t get that “big break”, even after a brief foray into “adult entertainment”. After getting fired from several jobs (gotta’ get to that new audition), he actually sleeps in an alley with his new bulldog pup, Butkis. Things take a turn for the better when he gets an usher job at a small cinema. There, Sly starts a romance with a tough but cute concession worker, Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb). She believes in him, even after meeting Sly’s dismissive papa, barber Frank Sr. (Matt Dillon). Sasha even convinces Sly to ditch his “stage name,” Mike. The two marry and relocate to LA, where she works as a photographer while he balances auditions with a gig as a hotel parking valet. He nearly gets a role with prestige movie-producing partners Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell). Instead of a job, Sly gets a “chance” when he tells them of his writing aspirations, slipping his script to the top of their towering “to be read” pile. Irwin and Bob are impressed, but don’t see a market for his “rasslin” tale, “Paradise Alley”, asking him, “Got anything else?” Sly gets an idea at his local bar, where he watches a big heavyweight bout between “the greatest” Muhhammed Ali and the unknown ” Chuck Wepner. For the next three days, he stays awake (barely), writing in longhand (with Sasha typing it up) the story of a fighter who gets his “shot” at the title, Rocky Balboa. The producers are impressed, thinking this is a great script for Eastwood or Bronson. But no, Sly will not let the screenplay go unless he plays Rocky. The head of United Artists, Sandy Maddox (Tracy Letts), begrudgingly wants it for a “name” and tells “the boys” to offer more money for the script. But with each higher offer (climbing another few grand, then another), Sly won’t bend. When they get a “green light”, the challenges really begin as they deal with a tiny budget and near-endless obstacles. But just like the story’s underdog hero, the “movie team” believes that they’re “gonna fly, now”.

This story is elevated beyond “made for cable TV” fodder (y’know, the “unauthorized, behind the scenes” nostalgia rehash) by the exceptional cast. And it all rests on the broad, chiseled shoulders (not to mention the soulful “half-mast” eyes) of Ippolito. He avoids the “cartoonized” Sly done by countless comedians and impressionists and imbues him with a “dreamer’s heart”. Mind you, the resemblance is uncanny, vocally and physically (he also was great as young Al Pacino in the well-done streaming series, “The Offer”, about the making of THE GODFATHER). Much as with Jamie Foxx as RAY or Cate Blanchett as Kate Hepburn in THE AVIATOR, you just accept him as the screen icon in a performance that’s much, much more than mimicry. Ippolito also has great chemistry with Robb as the tough but supportive Sasha, a kindred spirit for this journey, who can ‘take the wheel” when needed. There’s a splendid screen “comedy team” formed by Byrne and Kebbell, whose Winler and Chartoff have as strong and focused a relationship as Sly and Sasha. Their “tag-team blitz’ is needed against the scene-stealing, powerhouse work from Letts as the impatient, foul-mouthed, and cagey (he still winces about a missed box office smash) studio head. He really excels at these cranky authority figures. Another “cinematic heist’ is committed by Dillon, who actually brings some warmth to the disparaging daddy who tries to derail this “movie train” . There are also terrific supporting turns from Stephen James as Carl Weathers, adhering to the old actor’s habit of lying about abilities (the old “say yes, I can to everything”), and “for reals” filmmaker Jay Duplass as aggressively blunt (” Ask anyone…I’m an a-hole!”) director John Alvidson. And kudos to Nikki Tyler-Flynn as the best secretary anyone could ask for and the winning Kiki Seto as Talia Shire.

And it’s another “solid score” (almost a KO) from director Peter Farrelly (yes, that string of hit comedy smashes with his brother Bobby), who helmed the 2018 Best Picture Oscar-winner THE GREEN BOOK (but was “against the ropes” with mediocre follow-ups like THE GREATEST BEER RUN EVER). He’s back on track with another big, audience-pleasing entertainment that’s all about a film that had moviegoers cheering fifty years ago (I certainly heard them from my seat). The screenplay from Peter Gamble (how appropriate, considering the subject) deftly weaves together the legendary behind-the-scenes struggles and shenanigans that Sly enjoyed spilling in countless interviews, though the film takes a few minor liberties ( and no Mama Stallone or Frank Jr.). This might be the ultimate “Tinsletown” rags-to-riches story, which doesn’t completely canonize the man at its center. We feel his shame at the porno set, and later, join Sasha in her anger over being left out of the script negotiations. As to the “rags” scenes, this recreation of dirty and dangerous 1970s NYC is entirely convincing thanks to some stellar art direction, costuming, and hair styling. The bouncy pace slows a tad during the final “on location” scenes, but we’re back on board rooting for the big premiere, even though we know the outcome. Now, here’s a true family flick, one that you’ll be able to see with “Grammy” or your favorite uncle without getting fidgety (and not grabbing a quick cell-phone time-check… Grrr, I despise that). Sure, this may be “piggybacking” on our affection for that spirited 70′ sensation, but I PLAY ROCKY is just as rousing and inspiring on its own. And lots more fun than downing a big glass of raw eggs. Gulp!

3.5 Out of 5

I PLAY ROCKY is now playing in theatres everywhere