Lena Dunham and Stephen Fry play a daughter and her Holocaust-survivor father, on a trip to his native Poland in the 1990s, in the dramedy TREASURE. The trip is the daughter’s idea, and her plan is to learn about her family history, something her father and late mother always refused to talk about. Angry and frustrated at her parents’ refusal to share anything about their past, she plans to visit sites related to dad’s family and life to learn about the family she knows nothing about. Her father has steadfastly refused to talk about it, and with the death of her mother, she figured going to their home country of Poland was the only way. Unsurprisingly, revisiting Poland is not something dad wanted to do but he goes along, pretty much uninvited, to “protect her,” as he puts it. What he is protecting her from is a little unclear.
This pair couldn’t be more different in temperament, and have a prickly relationship. The daughter, Ruth (Lena Dunham), is grim, humorless, and no-nonsense, a New York-based music journalist, a vegan with rigid habits, who doesn’t seem to enjoy travel and worries about her tight budget. Dad Edek (Stephen Fry) is a joyful, outgoing fellow, who stops to flirt with most women he meets along the way and tells everyone they meet that his daughter is rich and famous, although she is neither. He refuses to be serious, at least on the surface, and Dad does his best to distract his daughter, to delay things, waste time, and send her on the wrong track, even trick her, to keep her from her mission. He is sometimes helped by a local taxi driver (Stefan Zbigniew Zamachowski) that the pair have picked up at the airport and turned into a kind of tour guide, after dad refuses to board the train his daughter had booked for the trip.
Julia von Heinz wrote and directs this dramedy about family, memory and Poland in WWII and in post-communist 1990s. The story is emotional, and often funny. At first, the situation seems a bit forced, contrived and awkward, but as the story unfolds, the film improves and becomes more believable. Fry and Dunham soften and deepen their characters, and both father and daughter work through some issues. Zamachowski as the driver provides a mediator between battling father and daughter, and adds his own comedy touches or serves as a comic foil, while supplying information about the post-communist Poland as they travel.
Ruth is there to investigate her family’s history, not to have fun, so she goes about his trip like a woman on a mission, or working an assignment. But her trip does include some educational tours, mostly because she has so few clues from her parents, both to learn about Poland and the Holocaust. The film does note how odd it is to have such tours of sites like Auschwitz. As admirable as it is to educate people, with the aim of “never again,” it is still seems strange and unsettling to have them as tourist sites. However, Ruth is mostly there to learn about her family. She has done some research and also visits places like a family cemetery and a one-time family home. But the closer she gets to the family sites, the more smiling, fast-talking dad seems desperate to derail her search.
Both Dunham and Fry are good, with Fry especially charming and funny. Early one, some odd-couple humor feels forced, but as things go along, the film improves as Fry’s and Dunham’s characters become more relaxed. Fry’s Edek is quite a plotter but slowly becomes less a hindrance, even revealing why he has been so secretive all these years. The film touches on true-history subjects, such as giving insight on how neighbors turned on their Jewish friends and neighbors, exploiting the Nazi occupation for their own advantage. Eventually the meaning of the title is revealed, in a twist that brings father and daughter together at last.
TREASURE debuts streaming on demand on Tuesday, July 30.
RATING: 3 out of 4 stars
