EAST OF WALL – Review

EAST OF WALL is a low-key, low-budget, indie docu-drama, set near the South Dakota Badlands and just east of the town of Wall (home to the famous Wall Drug), where a youngish widowed rancher trains and rehabilitates rescued horses, the horses that no one wants, with the help of her teen daughters and gaggle of foster kids, mostly girls, who were abandoned or neglected by their own families. The rancher/cowgirl sells the rehabilitated horses at auction, to make a bare-bones living to support the kids and herself. EAST OF WALL’s greatest strength is its affecting portrait of this remarkable real woman doing her best to save both cast-off horses and neglected teens. That feeling is amplified by the docu-drama’s moving cinematography of the windswept scenery of the Badlands, with plenty of horses carrying joyful stunt-riding teens.

EAST OF WALL won the 2025 Sundance Film Festival Audience Award for its affecting mix of documentary and family drama set in a striking western landscape. Writer/director Kate Beecroft was inspired to write this fictionalized tale after meeting rancher/horse trainer Tabatha Zimiga, a modern cowgirl in the New West. Shortly after Beecroft pulled off the rural road in South Dakota and onto Tabatha’s large ranch, she was introduced to a group of confident teen-aged girls, their hair half-shaved in warrior fashion, who poured out of a trailer and hopped onto horses. Tabatha invited Beecroft into their lives, and the result is this fly-on-the-wall drama that draws heavily on the reality of this family and life in this rural community.

In EAST OF WALL, Tabatha Zimiga stars as a version of herself, and along with her daughter Porshia, leads a cast of mostly non-actors, in a family drama of feminist grit, courage and commitment. The non-actor cast is supported by a couple of pros, Scoot McNairy as a prosperous horse buyer from Texas and Jennifer Ehle as Tabatha’s tough-gal mother Tracey, who lives on the spacious, ramshackle ranch with Tabatha and her teen charges.

Clearly, Tabitha has a good heart and a strong sense of responsibility but she is no sweet, timid flower. Frank, tattooed and often foul-mouthed, Tabitha is a rough-and-tumble cowgirl of the New West, who was raised by a tough, hard-drinking mother who had a hard life. They are surrounded by a circle of equally rough-edged women friends, plus a community of people, a mix of white and Indigenous, who also are struggling with their own hard lives, often amid an assortment of problems including abusive relationships, heavy drinking, and dysfunction. Tabatha is trying her best to keep her family together, to encourage the kids in her charge and to empower them, through what they can do for these unwanted horses.

To support the family, Tabatha sells the rehabilitated horses at local auctions, and sometimes even on TikTok, with the girls helping demonstrate how well-trained the horses are by performing stunt-riding tricks with them. But it is a struggle, profits are small, and they are on the edge financially. Tabatha worries about making a living and holding onto the ranch she inherited from her beloved husband.

Into this dire financial picture comes a new buyer, a man from Texas with deep pockets named Roy (Scoot McNairy). Roy offers to buy Tabatha’s ranch and then hired her and her teens as trainers for horses, which he will then sell in Texas for much higher prices. But Tabatha is wary and uncertain about the offer, so they enter into a temporary arrangement while she considers it.

EAST OF WALL leans heavily into observational documentary, and moves at a languid pace until late in the film. This gives the audience plenty of time to take in details of this hardscrabble life of rodeos, horse auctions, and honky-tonk bars but does not serve the fictional plot as well. Many of the people we meet are wanderers, following rodeos or dreams, while often struggling with past or even present of abuse, alcoholism and broken families. Tabatha represents a steady strength in that sea of chaotic lives, and ground that strength in her love for caring for both horses and kids.

The fictional story line is thin, enough so that one might wish that director/writer Beecroft had chosen instead to make this film as just a documentary. Scoot McNairy and Jennifer Ehle turn in nice performances, as does the cast of non-actors, but it takes awhile for the story to get going.

However, the film’s cinematographer Austin Shelton takes full advantage of the striking scenery of the Badlands. There is plenty of footage of the teens riding and doing stunts in that landscape, as well at the auctions and rodeos. The docu-drama gives a frank, slice-of-life look at this world, with various people drifting in and out, and shots of the ranch, littered with discarded cars, mining and farm equipment, as the kids hang out and bond with each other.

The slow pacing, until near the end, does not serve the fictional part of the film particularly well but audiences may still be drawn in by the real people in this film and it’s rare glimpse into a little-see world in the modern west, and particularly by the remarkable Tabatha doing her excellent, admirable work. The glimpse into that world, and the spotlight this film throws on this strong woman doing good work in rescuing both horses and teens, makes it worth a little extra patience and an ultimately rewarding experience.

EAST OF WALL opens in theaters on Friday, Aug. 15, 2025.

RATING: 2.5 out of 4 stars