LABOR DAY – The Review

By  |  1 Comment


Were it better, LABOR DAY might well strike a seductive chord for romantics: a dreamy escaped convict hovers over a mother and son he’s taken hostage over a holiday weekend. One so full of love, cooking, and romance, it will change their lives forever. But the film, based on the Joyce Maynard novel, is so trapped in a dreary Nicolas Sparks-style cliche-ridden universe that we know the entire plot from the start to the over-sentimental climax. LABOR DAY stars Kate Winslet and Josh Brolin, two usually solid actors, but they’re wasted as LABOR DAY neither raises the pulse nor unintentionally entertains and while some may eat this mush up, most will see it as a tremendous disappointment from writer/director Jason Reitman (of JUNO and UP IN THE AIR fame).

LABOR DAY centers on 13-year-old Henry Wheeler, who cares for his mopey, reclusive mother Adele (Winslet) after his dad (Clark Gregg), fed up with her depression, leaves them for his secretary. On a back-to-school shopping trip, Adele and Henry are confronted by Frank Chambers (Brolin), a convicted murderer injured after escaping from the nearby prison who convinces the pair to take him into their home (since he’s unarmed, it’s not clear why she doesn’t yell for help in the store, but it’s that kind of movie). Once there, he ties his captives to a chair for about ten minutes. Then he unties them and cooks chili. Then he bakes biscuits. Then he prepares a perfectly photogenic peach pie, working the dough with his rugged man-hands Swayze-style and whispering seductively in Adele’s ear “Pie crust is a very forgiving thing” (where’s Diablo Cody when you need her? Does his junk smell like pie?). He fixes the broken door, repairs the car, waxes the floor, cleans the gutters, plays catch with Henry, mends Adele’s aching depression with his masterful massage techniques, and assembles some Ikea furniture. I made that last one up but….wow, what a man! (he and Adele sweat a lot too but I’m unclear whether or not they have sex – I don’t think they do – but I could be wrong – maybe I missed something!) As Frank and Adele plan a Canadian getaway, an endless series of flashbacks inform us he’s not really a cold-blooded double murderer at all. He killed his baby kinda sorta by accident, and that slutty wife of his, the one that died after banging her head on the radiator when he shoved her…..she may have had it coming. Meanwhile, to pad out the slim story, Henry begins a friendship with a movie-wise young girl (Brighid Fleming).

Reitman’s adaptation of Ms Maynard’s novel plods along with dialogue somewhere around the level of bad Harlequin, and his direction is sluggish and fails to build a speck of tension. I liked YOUNG ADULT but thought it was a step backwards for the usually reliable writer/director, whose JUNO and UP IN THE AIR were such standouts, but LABOR DAY is his worst film yet. Brolin can play these hunky lugs in his sleep but Ms Winslet can’t seem to get a grip on her character. There’s a scene where she and Henry nervously withdraw her life savings before hitting the road with Mr. Perfect. The bank employees are leery – “this is suspicious” the bank manager exclaims and Winslet’s overly nervous fluttering is all wrong for the scene. Blame the director for not coaxing a better performance from his star but everybody acts illogically in LABOR DAY. Frank’s idea of ‘laying low’ is to repair the roof even though there’s a wanted poster with his mug on it tacked on a phone pole out front. And why is everyone in this town such busybodies? A nosy neighbor (Brooke Smith) with a disabled son keeps popping into Adele’s home unannounced, clerks at the local market ask meddlesome questions, and the local cop (James VanDer Beek) follows Adele inside her home even though she asks him not to. And why is Henry, presented late in the film as a tall, broad-shouldered older teen, played in epilogue as an adult by runty Tobey Maguire? On the plus side, the two leads are attractive enough to hold interest for a while and the cinematography is nice to look at. The camera often pans up to offer a graceful look at tree branches as the sunlight peeks through while Rolfe Kent’s sappy score swoons. But they’re lovely shots in a production prettified, safe, and bland…..and lame.

1 of 5 Stars


1 Comment

  1. Lisa

    February 6, 2014 at 12:42 am

    Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but I definitely disagree with this review entirely.

    For instance, I’m not quite sure how a relation to Nicholas Sparks is even really remotely close – there are thousands of movies regarding forbidden love, drama, and the like, and while Nicholas Sparks’ movies usually involve the death of a loved one or even an over-the-top love story, I felt like the romance in this movie was depicted very well, and it wasn’t too cliche’. While all in all it could be conceived as a love story, there were a lot of bumps and struggles that make the movie inevitably almost realistic in a way: the struggle of opening up to someone, being hurt in the past, not understanding what love really is (Henry’s perception and also the realistic views from a seventh grader when he is talking to that young girl about sex and moving away), etc. That isn’t to say that Nicholas Sparks’ movies aren’t realistic, but to openly assume that this movie is too cliche’ is to imply that it’s a common love story, and almost too obvious – but I, as well as my friend who also saw the movie, completely disagree.

    As to Kate’s perceived lack of acting in this review, I don’t even know where one sees that. I would definitely argue that the bank scene was one of the better scenes in the movie. Her character went through a lot, with the shaking that she had, as well as the sweat seen throughout the movie on her as well as Frank – it was almost too realistic. Not to mention that Henry’s acting definitely complimented her “nervousness” in the movie.

    I’m not sure if you saw the house overall, but it’s a big one with a big backyard. Of course, if you saw someone nonchalantly working on a rooftop while driving, would you really be that concerned? Not to mention from a distance? It’s interesting how they made a big deal about his disappearance, but it could be that they were in a very small town (the employees at the bank knew Adele and her son by a first name basis). And what is wrong with Tobey Maguire?

    This review leaves too many ambiguity in the questions towards the end. As a review, these questions rather work against the statements made. Sorry, this review was a “tremendous disappointment”, to say the least.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>